4. The “I Am Your Father” Thing Is Questionable
Considering the dialogue, the entire thing doesn’t make sense by any means. That is truly on account of the way that George Lucas never planned on having Luke and Vader to be connected. Not until he set out upon this film and concluded that it would be much cooler if the two were connected. He was correct; however there are few issues characteristic to this small twist. As it is, it changes the primary motion picture completely. Incidentally, this means that Obi-Wan lied to Luke for reasons unknown about the whereabouts of his dad. At the time that A New Hope was made, Obi-Wan’s dialogue should be true, yet this turn renders him dishonest. Furthermore, Darth Vader tries to kill Luke toward the end of A New Hope amid the Battle of Yavin. Would he not have detected that he was endeavoring to murder his son? It’s a lot like retconning.
3. No Proper Ending In The Empire Strikes Back
The Empire Strikes Back is often thought to be the best of all the Star Wars movies. In the event that you happen to trust that films ought to exist as independent entities, with their own beginnings, middles, and endings, then Empire misses the mark. Joss Whedon, writer and director stated that The Empire Strikes Back committed the cardinal sin of not really ending.
